Wind annoyances

Wind turbineWindmills are an interesting and challenging frontier in environmental regulation, as this story from the New York Times suggests. This fellow Michael Mercurio, who’s in the windmill business, put one up on his Cape Cod property and is now fighting tooth and nail with his neighbours:

Some of his neighbors say it is also annoying. They say it is too big. They say it is too noisy. And some residents in this middle-class borough on Long Beach Island have gone to court to try to make him take it down, while the township has stilled it since winter.

“I don’t understand why they are against this[,” Mercurio says, “]I really don’t.”

Maybe because, as Mr. Mercurio’s neighbors Patricia Caplicki and John Miller say in the lawsuit, in a 14-mile-per-hour wind, the three fiberglass blades produce noise greater than 50 decibels, the rough equivalent of light traffic or a noisy refrigerator.

The suit also says that the spinning blades throw “strobe-like shadows” on their property from noon to sunset.

According to the Times, the windmill and additional solar panels cut Mercurio’s electricity and gas bills from something like $4,000 a year to $114, suggesting it’s a significant environmental improvement. This kind of distributed, consumer-controlled generation is a good thing because of that, because it means individuals are taking responsibility for linking their consumption to where power comes from, and because it means a more resilient generation system overall.

That said, I can understand somebody not wanting a 35-foot-high windmill looming over his or her yard, particularly if the business about the strobe effect is true, and I don’t imagine it’d be pleasant to inhabit a neighbourhood forested with them. It’s not that it’s unpleasant to look at, but that it has a deleterious effect on the neighbours whether they look at it or not.
Lots of harmless property improvements — solar-powered water heaters, say, or new kinds of insulation — are effectively forbidden under zoning codes because they’re not specifically permitted, and without official standards, they can’t be inspected. This is dangerously silly; if I want to stick some panels on the roof of my house, that’s nobody’s business but mine, and perhaps my insurance company’s.

In cases such as Mr. Mercurio’s, though, there’s doubtless a role for the local government in setting limits on what you can do that affects other people’s enjoyment of their property. If you couldn’t put up an antenna or an advertisement that does certain things, you probably shouldn’t be treated different just because your goal is environmental rather than commercial.

 Photo credit: “Wind turbine,” Flickr/Lepti


2 responses to “Wind annoyances

  1. I can’t help but think that people complaining about “noise pollution” and “aesthetics” are using such arguments to front a conservative agenda. With the number of billboards, telephone wires, water towers, air conditioning units, and noise pollution caused by the general populace (cars, industry, etc.)I can’t help but scoff at such poor excuses to target a man who is reducing the amount of actual air pollution and/or toxic waste generated in the community on property that he rightfully owns. What happened to America’s independent spirit, and the right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness?

  2. I don’t generally have much sympathy for people who, say, own waterfront property and refuse to countenance windmills anywhere in their fields of view.

    But if there’s a 35-foot-high turbine 30 feet from my bedroom, making an audible hum any time there’s wind 365 days a year (including at night, when I might like my windows open), and having a strobe effect in my home … well, I can see how that sort of thing might tick even an open-minded neighbour off.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s