Britain’s aged socialist icon Tony Benn demonstrates why socialists can’t be trusted with environmental policy as he denounces the idea of tradeable personal carbon allowances.
I’m not hot on the idea myself, which is being kicked around by Britain’s current environment minister, because I can’t imagine any government introducing something just about as complex as a second currency to any modern economy without screwing it up — actually, probably more complex than a second currency, because its value would have to be re-pegged periodically according to how much carbon … — look, anyway, nobody could get it right.
But get a load of Benn:
In the war it was a criminal offence for me to sell my ration book to somebody else, because the purpose of the rationing was to see that everybody had a fair share … If we need to ration [carbon expenditure] that’s one thing, but fair distribution is the key to it. If the world is short of resources we have to ration them, which is different from selling them… The earth is a common treasure; it is a crime to buy and sell it for personal gain.
So in Benn’s vision, virtue cannot be rewarded. Also, during the war, nobody traded rations of stuff they didn’t want to get stuff they did, and if they did, it was wrong. Why would anybody listen to this?